Live Forest HillsJason Gruner Coldwell Banker

News / October 23, 2026

57 Annandale, a Forest Hills note

Jason Gruner, REALTOR, Coldwell Banker Southern Realty

Front exterior of 57 Annandale in Forest Hills Nashville. A two story stucco and stacked stone home with dormers and a balcony above the entry, set up on a hill with curving stone steps, stacked stone retaining walls, a green lawn, boxwoods and mature trees

57 Annandale is a Forest Hills house I wrote about while it was listed. I would still be glad to talk through it with you. It is a custom built stacked stone and stucco home in the gated community of Otter Wood, Nashville, TN 37215, last listed at $2,495,000. The count is 4 bedrooms, 4 full baths, and 2 half baths, across 5,551 square feet. The house was built in 1996 on 1.76 acres. The listing calls the lot one of the most picturesque and serene lots in the community. What caught my eye is the main level owner's suite, with direct access to the rear patio. I am Jason Gruner with Coldwell Banker Southern Realty. As of November 5, 2026 this house is no longer on the market in my Forest Hills search. I am not calling it sold.

57 Annandale at a glance

Price$2,495,000
StatusOff market
Beds / baths4 beds / 4 full / 2 half
Square feet5,551
Year built1996
Lot1.76 acres
SubdivisionOtter Wood (gated)
MLS #3223002
Listing agentDonnie Stanley, Compass

Inside the home

The house is 4 bedrooms, 4 full baths, and 2 half baths, across 5,551 square feet, built in 1996. The listing describes a custom built stacked stone and stucco home, with hardwoods, detailed millwork, high ceilings, and spacious rooms designed for entertaining.

The main level holds the living and dining rooms, an office with built ins and wainscoting panels, an open family room, a kitchen with Wolf and Sub Zero appliances, and a breakfast room with natural light. The family room has hardwood floors, a white fireplace, crown molding, and a wall of French doors looking out to the trees.

In the kitchen, white cabinetry wraps the walls. A dark island has a white top, with black pendant lights above it. A stainless range hood marks the cooking line. There is a built in refrigerator, and windows sit over the sink.

The main level owner's suite has direct access to the rear patio. The listing describes a separate soaking tub, a large marble shower, and separate walk in closets.

Upstairs, three large secondary bedrooms share the level with a 36 by 21 foot recreation room. That room has a built in snack bar, a beverage center, and an ice maker. MLS number 3223002.

Family room with hardwood floors, a white fireplace, crown molding and a wall of French doors looking out to the trees at 57 Annandale in Forest Hills Nashville
Kitchen with white cabinetry, a dark island with a white top, black pendant lights, a stainless range hood, a built in refrigerator and windows over the sink at 57 Annandale in Forest Hills Nashville

Outdoor space and the lot

The lot is 1.76 acres, wooded, with steps from the rear patio leading to trails within the wooded lot. The listing calls it one of the most picturesque and serene lots in Otter Wood.

A full length rear patio is bordered by a landscaped stacked stone wall with a built in water feature. Landscaped grounds come with exterior lighting and a full irrigation system. The covered rear patio opens to the stacked stone wall and water feature, with wooded hillside plantings and a stone paved terrace.

From above, the home sits among dense mature trees on this wooded lot. The listing places the house next to Richland Country Club.

Covered rear patio opening to a stacked stone wall with a water feature, wooded hillside plantings and a stone paved terrace at 57 Annandale in Forest Hills Nashville

Why Otter Wood works in Forest Hills

This address is on Annandale, in the gated community of Otter Wood, Nashville, TN 37215. The lot is 1.76 wooded acres. I still start with beds, baths, budget, timing, and property type.

The listing places 57 Annandale next to Richland Country Club. 55 Annandale is another Otter Wood home, and it already has its own note. Read that note if you want the other house. This note stays on 57 Annandale. Annandale Nashville is the street name on both addresses.

Forest Hills real estate inside a gate is still one address at a time. Homes for sale in Forest Hills Nashville TN are worth reading one address at a time.

The buyer incentive

When the house was listed, the seller was offering a $50,000 buyer incentive. A buyer could use it toward a rate buydown, remodeling, closing costs, or as an additional price reduction. The incentive was applicable with an offer acceptable to the seller.

Living in Forest Hills, one of Nashville's best neighborhoods

Otter Wood is the gated community. The City of Forest Hills is the map around that gate. When I place 57 Annandale I still say what the city is, so the gate is not mistaken for the city limit.

Forest Hills is its own incorporated city in Davidson County, with a mayor and a commission of its own. City Hall is at 6300 Hillsboro Pike. The edges I use are Old Hickory Boulevard on the south, Granny White Pike on the east, Harding Place on the north, and Chickering Road and Belle Meade on the west. I work in this city. Forest Hills Nashville is the place name on that city limit. I use those edges so a gated street still has a place on the same map as the rest of the city. When people ask me about the best Nashville neighborhoods, I start with those edges and then come back to the house. Above this lot, dense mature trees stand around the home.

Aerial view of the home among dense mature trees on its wooded lot at 57 Annandale in Forest Hills Nashville

The Forest Hills market right now

As of my October 23, 2026 Realtracs snapshot of core Forest Hills (37215 only): 35 active, 6 pending, 16 closed in the last three months, average sold price $3,256,275, median about $2,445,000, average 68 days on market.

That snapshot is on the Market page so you can read it next to the monthly sold table. This note is not an Active listing as of November 5, 2026. The last list price on this note is $2,495,000. I am not calling it sold. The average sold price is not a value for this address, and the average days on market on closed sales is not a promise for how this listing will move. If you want the houses still for sale, use Homes for Sale.

Forest Hills FAQ

What is the price of 57 Annandale?

The last list price on this note is $2,495,000. As of November 5, 2026 it is no longer on the market in my Forest Hills search. I am not calling it sold. The house is 4 bedrooms, 4 full baths, and 2 half baths, with 5,551 square feet, built in 1996, on 1.76 acres in gated Otter Wood. MLS number 3223002. The listing agent and brokerage are credited at the end of this note. When it was listed, the seller was offering a $50,000 buyer incentive, applicable with an offer acceptable to the seller.

What do Forest Hills homes cost right now?

As of my October 23, 2026 Realtracs snapshot of core Forest Hills (37215 only): 35 active, 6 pending, 16 closed in the last three months, average sold price $3,256,275, median about $2,445,000, average 68 days on market. The last list price on this note is $2,495,000, below that average and above that median. As of November 5, 2026 the house is no longer on the market in my Forest Hills search. I am not calling it sold. The average is not the price of this address.

How fast do Forest Hills homes sell?

That same October 23, 2026 snapshot shows an average of 68 days on market on the closed sales in the three month window. That figure describes homes that already closed. It is not a forecast for 57 Annandale, and it is not a promise that this house will move on that timetable.

What does the listing say is beside 57 Annandale?

The address is 57 Annandale in gated Otter Wood, Nashville, TN 37215, on a 1.76 acre wooded lot. The listing places the house next to Richland Country Club. 55 Annandale, another Otter Wood home, has its own note. The City of Forest Hills is its own incorporated city in Davidson County.

More Forest Hills homes for sale

If you want homes that are for sale now, start with Homes for Sale. The market snapshot is on the Market page. About Forest Hills has the map notes. The other links are more notes.

If you want to talk through 57 Annandale with me, use the contact page and send the criteria in writing: beds, baths, budget, timing, and property type. I will tell you whether a house like this matches before we set a time.

Jason Gruner, REALTOR, Coldwell Banker Southern Realty

Listed by Donnie Stanley | Compass

Back to News

Explore more in Forest Hills

If you want the neighborhood notes, the homes for sale page, or this month sold table, I keep those here.

Monthly Forest Hills price report

The table I actually use: sold prices, square footage, and days on market.

I publish it at foresthillshomesreport.com. Every closed sale, address by address, with price, size, and days on market.

Get this month's report