News / October 21, 2026
5623 Hillsboro Pike among Forest Hills homes for sale
Jason Gruner, REALTOR, Coldwell Banker Southern Realty

5623 Hillsboro Pike is one of the Forest Hills homes for sale I would be glad to walk with you. It is a 2023 McAlpine custom home designed by Ray Booth, with 8,180 square feet on nearly five private, gated acres in Nashville, TN 37215, offered fully furnished and listed at $23,500,000. The count is 5 bedrooms, 5 full baths, and 2 half baths. What caught my eye is the chef's kitchen, with an eight burner BlueStar range and a window that lifts into the ceiling to open the kitchen to the screened porch. Outside there is an oversized saltwater pool, a guest house, a private gym, and a pickleball court. I am Jason Gruner. As of October 21, 2026 the house is Active.
5623 Hillsboro Pike at a glance
| Price | $23,500,000 |
|---|---|
| Status | Active |
| Beds / baths | 5 beds / 5 full / 2 half |
| Square feet | 8,180 |
| Year built | 2023 |
| Lot | nearly 5 acres |
| MLS # | 3180591 |
| Listing agent | Cathie Cato Renken, French King Fine Properties |
Inside the home
The house is 5 bedrooms, 5 full baths, and 2 half baths, across 8,180 square feet. It was built in 2023. Ray Booth designed this McAlpine custom home, and it is offered fully furnished.
The living room is where I would start the walk. Cream upholstered seating faces a black fireplace. The ceiling is pale wood, with a sculptural chandelier. A wood coffee table holds ceramic vessels and white flowers, and a gray chair sits in front of the seating.
The kitchen and the dining room share one volume. A green marble island has woven leather stools and glass pendants. The dining table sits under a long white pendant, with dark wood chairs and caramel leather seats. The range is an eight burner BlueStar, with a black hood and a dark marble backsplash, and light wood cabinets on either side. A window in this kitchen lifts into the ceiling and opens the room to the screened porch. MLS number 3180591.



Outdoor space and the lot
The lot is nearly five private, gated acres. The covered porch has a dark stone floor and a lantern overhead, and it opens toward an oversized saltwater pool. Lounge seating lines the pool, and a white gabled guest house stands across the water. A private gym and a pickleball court are on the grounds as well.
From the front, the house reads as two wings. The left wing is light siding, with a steep gable and a bay of windows. The right wing is brick, with dormers and a long run of windows. A large tree stands in front of the brick, above a lawn and a drive.

Why Hillsboro Pike works in Forest Hills
This address is on Hillsboro Pike in Nashville, TN 37215. The lot is nearly five acres, private and gated. Two other Hillsboro Pike houses already have their own notes, 6204 Hillsboro Pike and 6004 Hillsboro Pike, and those notes are the place to read the other houses.
Forest Hills real estate at this price is still one house at a time. Homes for sale in Forest Hills Nashville TN are worth reading one address at a time. If you are comparing houses, start with beds, baths, budget, timing, and property type, then we can set a time to walk this one.
Living in Forest Hills, one of Nashville's best neighborhoods
5623 Hillsboro Pike sits on the corridor through Forest Hills. I still use Radnor Lake, on the east side, when I place a pike address on the wider map.
Radnor Lake State Natural Area is the landmark I use on the east side of Forest Hills. It is a Tennessee state natural area of more than 1,300 acres, just east of the city, on Otter Creek Road off Granny White Pike. The visitor center is at 1160 Otter Creek Road. The State of Tennessee runs the park. The City of Forest Hills does not own it. I use Radnor to place a home on a map. When people ask me about the best Nashville neighborhoods, I start with a map fact like this before I talk about any one house. Forest Hills Nashville sits beside that park.
The Forest Hills market right now
As of my October 20, 2026 snapshot of core Forest Hills (37215 only): 34 active, 7 pending, 17 closed in the last three months, average sold price $3,242,965, median about $2,300,000, average 79 days on market.
That snapshot is on the Market page so you can read it next to the monthly sold table. This note is one Active house at $23,500,000. The average sold price is not a value for this address, and the average days on market on closed sales is not a promise for how this listing will move. If you want the houses still for sale, use Homes for Sale.
Forest Hills FAQ
What is the price of 5623 Hillsboro Pike?
The list price is $23,500,000. Status is Active. The house is 5 bedrooms, 5 full baths, and 2 half baths, with 8,180 square feet, built in 2023, on nearly five private, gated acres. It is a McAlpine custom home designed by Ray Booth, offered fully furnished. MLS number 3180591. The listing agent and brokerage are credited at the end of this note.
What do Forest Hills homes cost right now?
As of my October 20, 2026 snapshot of core Forest Hills (37215 only): 34 active, 7 pending, 17 closed in the last three months, average sold price $3,242,965, median about $2,300,000, average 79 days on market. This house is listed at $23,500,000, above that average and above that median. The average is not the price of this address.
How fast do Forest Hills homes sell?
That same October 20, 2026 snapshot shows an average of 79 days on market on the closed sales in the three month window. That figure describes homes that already closed. It is not a forecast for 5623 Hillsboro Pike, and it is not a promise that this house will move on that timetable.
What is near 5623 Hillsboro Pike?
The address is 5623 Hillsboro Pike, Nashville, TN 37215, on nearly five private, gated acres. Hillsboro Pike is the corridor through Forest Hills. When I place that pike on a wider map, I use Radnor Lake State Natural Area, just east of the city on Otter Creek Road off Granny White Pike. The visitor center is at 1160 Otter Creek Road.
More Forest Hills homes for sale
If you want more Forest Hills homes for sale than this one address, start with Homes for Sale. The market snapshot is on the Market page. About Forest Hills has the map notes. The other links are more homes for sale.
If you want to walk 5623 Hillsboro Pike with me, use the contact page and send the criteria in writing: beds, baths, budget, timing, and property type. I will tell you whether this house matches before we set a time.
Jason Gruner, REALTOR, Coldwell Banker Southern Realty
Listed by Cathie Cato Renken | French King Fine Properties
Back to News